Status Report

CPC/RCMP Independent Observer to Monitor Impartiality of Investigation into the Police Involved Shooting Death of a Male in Nanaimo, B.C.

Ottawa, October 30, 2009 – On October 23, 2009, Nanaimo RCMP responded to a report of a noise complaint. When officers arrived, they encountered a male, later identified as Jeffrey Hughes. Given the nature of the subject's response to police, the members withdrew and contained the residence, requesting the attendance of the Emergency Response Team and a police service dog. Paramedics were also asked to stand by. While officers awaited the arrival of these specialized units, the suspect came out of the residence. A confrontation ensued between Mr. Hughes and the officers and shots were fired by police striking Mr. Hughes. Emergency medical attention was provided but the suspect was pronounced dead at the scene.

Based on information received, the CPC Chair, on October 23, 2009, requested that the CPC Observer be engaged to:

• Make an initial assessment as to the impartiality of the Major Crime Unit assigned to investigate this incident; and
• Monitor progress so as to ensure that any future issues as they relate to the impartiality of the investigation are identified and addressed.

The CPC Observer has completed an initial assessment as to the impartiality of the investigative team and concludes that there are currently no issues as they relate to questions of impartiality. The CPC Observer continues to monitor the investigation.

The Role of the Observer

The civilian Independent Observer assesses the impartiality of the RCMP team conducting the investigation. Factors that may be used to assess impartiality include the relative rank of the investigator or whether the member of the investigative team has ever:

• worked with or been stationed at the same detachment with any RCMP member who is the subject of the investigation;
• had a social relationship or social interaction with any RCMP member who is the subject of the investigation;
• attended training at Depot (troopmate) during the same period with any RCMP member who is the subject of the investigation; or
• been stationed or has worked at the detachment in which the investigation is taking place.

Additionally, the Independent Observer identifies any other factor that could affect the perception of impartiality as it relates to the investigative member participating in the investigation, such as comments made by the members of the investigative team to one another, to the Independent Observer or to any other person.

The IOP is aimed at enhancing public confidence in RCMP-led investigations into its own members with respect to the impartiality of the RCMP team conducting the investigation.

More information on the Independent Observer Program along with the IOP protocol can be found on the CPC website at http://www.cpc-cpp.gc.ca.

– 30 –

For more information, please contact:

Nelson Kalil
Manager, Communications
613-952-2452
nelson.kalil@cpc-cpp.gc.ca